When A Post Flops – Let’s Talk Bookish

Hi friends, welcome back to the blog! It’s been a while. The semester is thankfully halfway over, and the break will soon finally be here. I hope the past month has been kind to you all, and if not, hopefully this month will be much better.

It’s Friday, and I’m back to finally participate in LTB after so long. Quick note: I missed out on posting the topics for December last week, but you can find Dani’s announcement for them here, and I’ll work on adding them to the official Let’s Talk Bookish page hopefully by the end of today.

Let’s Talk Bookish is a weekly meme hosted by me and Dani @ Literary Lion where we discuss certain topics, share our opinions, and spread the love by visiting each other’s posts. Today’s topic is about when blog posts don’t do very well. Join in on this meme by writing your own discussion on the topic, and sharing your link using the inLinkz available here.

Without further ado, let’s get started.

The prompt for this topic is:

Imagine you’ve spent several hours, even days, perfecting a post that you’re so excited to publish. Finally, you hit publish and eagerly await the response. But the response is not as much as you’d expected, or worse, it’s nonexistent. Has that happened to you before? How do you handle poor post results? Do you think there’s usually a cause for poor post results?

I feel like every blogger has experienced this at one point or another. There’s always that one post that you put so much effort and time into writing and editing and designing, and you’re so. proud. of it, and can’t wait to share it with the world so everyone can enjoy all the effort you put in.

But then you do share it with the world and…the world doesn’t seem to care.

It hurts.

It really does.

And I think the way that it hurts is different depending on how long you’ve been blogging.

During my baby days as a newbie blogger, I decided to write a discussion post since I’d found a topic that I felt that I had a right to talk about. This was just my second month of blogging, and I’d been having some engagement with my other posts and I’d seen that discussions were popular in the community. So, I figured that I’d try my hand at writing one and was super excited for the comments that I knew would surely come.

I still acutely remember how worried I was when I was editing the post, and how I almost didn’t publish it because I felt like no one would care to read it. I’m just a tiny new blogger, who would care about my relatively inconsequential opinion?

Eventually, the post went live. The eager nervous waiting began. During those days, I watched my stats like a hawk; I was obsessed with the numbers, with getting comments and I always had a part of my brain trained and waiting for every new notification.

Nothing happened.

No comments.

No pingbacks.

No engagement.

It wasn’t until 3 months later that I finally got a comment on the post and by then, my initial excitement about foraying into the world of discussions had been completely and wholly crushed.

For me, as a new blogger, it made me feel insecure about my position within the community. Yes, I was just two months into it, but I was young, foolish, and naïve. To be perfectly honest, I’d hoped that the discussion would put my blog out there, and I’d suddenly get a boom in stats and followers and I would reach the level of all the bloggers that I adored.

Of course, that discussion didn’t do that. I didn’t get any comments at all on it initially, and it was just so crushing. I nearly took it down, because I figured that if I couldn’t even get one comment, then maybe I’d said something wrong or I was just that bad at writing discussions.

It also made me not want to write another discussion ever again.

Obviously, I eventually did write another discussion and then I started LTB, so I’ve kind of gotten over that. But I still remember how much it hurt me as a new blogger.

Now that I’ve been blogging for a few years, when a post that I was very excited to write doesn’t do well, i hide and disappear from the blogosphere I think I deal with it a lot better because it’s not the first time that it’s happened. It definitely still hurts and rattles my confidence, but I try to approach it logically and analyze the situation to figure out why the post flopped.

Perhaps it’s because I haven’t been engaging with the community lately*, perhaps the usual people who would comment on my posts aren’t around/are on hiatus, or perhaps it was just not a good day and the comments will come a little bit later.

* Mini Side Tangent

As much as we read each other’s posts because we love to, I think it’s also a give and take relationship where if someone comments on another person’s post, then they feel “obliged” to return the favor. It’s not obliged in a bad sense, it’s like it reminds them to check on the person’s blog and then they find something that they like and therefore comment on and the cycle of blog hopping and engagement in the community keeps going.

I feel like when you don’t bloghop, at least consistently, then it’s kind of easier for people to not remember to check on your posts.

But that’s what I’ve personally noticed. Does the same happen for you? Let me know in the comments below!

And sometimes I think that the timing of when I schedule a post matters as well, though I’m not 100% sure about that, but it’s another thing I consider. Maybe I posted it at a time I don’t usually post at and that could have contributed to the lack of engagement.

If you try multiple posts that are related to whatever it is that you wanted to talk about originally and they all don’t do that well, then I guess it’s a sign that your readers don’t really want to read about that.

Which is horrible, since you would love to write about it all day, but that’s the sad part about being content creators. Of course, it’s possible to find some readers who actually do love that kind of post and would read it, but not every post is going to work with all your readers.

One thing that I try to do if a post flops is to try and drive traffic to that post by mentioning it in other posts that I know will get good engagement. If people love your monthly wrap-ups and you get a lot of interaction with that, make sure you include the post that flopped there and talk about how much you loved writing it, and hopefully more people might go check it out.

You never know, it might just have been a bad day, or some readers might have missed it or forgotten that they were going to reply to it, so always keep that in mind and try not to take it to heart.

Lastly, I think it’s important that we remember why we’re blogging in the first place. Yes, getting engagement gives us validation, but at the same time, it shouldn’t be a do or die matter where if one post we were excited about doesn’t succeed, we give up on blogging altogether or we don’t try doing a similar post in the future.

Blogging can be tough, and there will be good times and bad times. Some posts will do better than others. Some that you’re excited about and proud of might not get the response that you want, but you just have to try and not let that define you or your worth as a blogger.

Some questions for you:

  • It’s been a while, so let’s chat: how have you been?
  • Have you ever experienced a post flopping? How did you handle it/what did you do? Do you think new and seasoned bloggers will react to a post not doing well differently?
  • Do you think there’s a give and take relationship when it comes to engagement in the community?

Share your thoughts in the comments below!

44 thoughts on “When A Post Flops – Let’s Talk Bookish

  1. I’m a newbie blogger and this post literally made me feel seen. I put out few posts thinking “oh people will like to read this” and then turns out, no one really cares. Ironically, the posts that I least expect to perform well end up gaining a lot of traction for some unknown reason. I try not to let the “views” make much of a difference but I definitely feel validated when more people read my posts. Nevertheless, I enjoy blogging and will continue to do so as long as I gain happiness from it.


  2. Great discussion! I still feel fairly new to blogging (I just celebrated by 2nd anniversary) but I only started my blog to get my bookish thoughts out of my head. 😉 I wanted to be immersed in the book community, but I didn’t necessarily care about comments or followers. I think starting that way has helped keep my expectations low. I first started joining in Top Ten Tuesday each week, visiting every blog that participated, discovering the bloggers who shared my interests. And when bloggers started reciprocating, I was surprised and thrilled. I definitely feel like it’s a give and take, which makes sense to me. But I only prioritize returning visits on Top Ten Tuesday posts. I try to with reviews and other posts, but I’m not too hard on myself if I don’t have time. I haven’t spent as much time dedicated to widely blog hopping this year as I did last year—and it shows in my stats—but I’m happy to be engaging with a small group of bloggers consistently, which means I get to discuss books to my heart’s content. ❤

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you, Dedra! Having the right approach and mindset would definitely help especially for new bloggers because it helps to curb unrealistic expectations. Wish I could go back in time and tell New Blogger Rukky that, haha. I’m so glad that you’re at a point where you are at peace with your stats and engagement though, that’s wonderful ❤✨


  3. Yeah it’s always the worst when posts you worked on a lot get barely any engagement (˃̣̣̥⌓˂̣̣̥ ) Sometimes I just have no idea why? Posts will just. Not get engagement for mysterious reasons and that’s that. Of course, sometimes my update schedule is very sporadic and I don’t think that helps. I really like your points about engagement not being the end-all-be-all, though. I didn’t care about engagement at all when I first started blogging, I really just wanted a way to get my words out into the void. Sometimes I can put too much emphasis on engagement, but it’s important to remember why I started!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. It’s just one of those random mysteries of the universe lol. There are so many little things that probably contribute to some posts flopping, but sometimes they also can’t be helped as life doesn’t pause for anyone.
      Thank you for reading ❤

      Liked by 1 person

    1. Oh, Diana, I’m so sorry. I think there are a couple of other factors as well that might play a role, but it must be so tough especially because you’ve been at it for so long. Please, don’t blame yourself though, that will only hurt you and your mental health. Your dedication is amazing, and I hope that you will find a wonderful audience that can relate and love your content as much as you do ❤

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Sometimes it is totally out of your hands. Back when I was on Blogspot, to begin with, I got hardly any hits to my posts. Then they changed the algorithm and suddenly I was getting dozens then hundreds of hits on my posts, but NO comments. Then they changed it yet again and BLAT, my stats fell through the floor, and still no comments. I was on Blogspot for YEARS and had 12 followers and a total of 5 (count them… FIVE) comments, one of which was my own! I moved to WP and lots changed. But there are still posts that flop from time to time, and I haven’t a clue why. Plus, there’s one old post that gets visits EVERY WEEK for a book that I didn’t care much for. I’m thinking it must be some SEO thing that brings traffic to one post but not another. Well, I can’t be bothered to work on SEO and adjust my style to push traffic to my blog, so… what comes, comes.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. That was one of the reasons why I never ended up going with Blogspot or Wix when I first started; they didn’t seem to have any built in engagement at all. WP is wonderful in the way that it connects related blogs and how much simpler it can be to keep track of everyone you’re following. Which is probably what helps make it such an engaging and popular platform for bloggers since Blogspot & Wix don’t have that. And yesss, I have one post that is visited every week, and it’s also for a book that I didn’t exactly scream about or anything; it was just a thrilling book that I reviewed. I think it’s partly because the ending was ambiguous so I mentioned some spoilers/theories for it in the review, so maybe that’s why it always gets traffic? I don’t even know at this point, but it’s so interesting, it probably has the most views out of any post I’ve ever written.

      Liked by 1 person

  5. I absolutely agree that other blogs aren’’t always top of mind on non-hop days. I get more hits on my blog on Tuesdays than all the other days combined because I am such a regular Top Ten Tuesday participant. On Tuesdays, I routinely read 60- 80 blogs and a decent percentage of those also hit my blog as well, and many of them hang out, and read other stuff I wrote throughout the week. I have a small group of pretty dedicated readers who read, like and comment almost every day, and I love them so much…but I admit that those days when EVERYONE is reading the blog feel pretty great, too.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes, those memes play a huge role in getting engagement, especially when you’re just starting and don’t have the established follower base that might check occasionally.
      Also, 60-80?? Wow, that’s impressive!! I don’t think I got up to 20 when I used to do TTT lol, which is kind of terrible of me, but it’s really amazing that you read so many!

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.